Real Wedding: Mikaela + Olivia at The Hillcrest Estate

Mikaela and Olivia went to the same tiny college. We're talking barely 500 students. Same classes, same dining hall, same everything.

They didn't actually meet until they were roommates in Florence, Italy.

Love really said, "Not yet. Let's make it romantic.”

Mikaela and Olivia posed after their ceremony at The Hillcrest Estate in Pavilion, NY Photo by Bree Renee Photography

The sign

Somewhere on the Mass Pike, there's a sign that proudly announces you've hit the highest elevation on I-90 east of the Rockies. It's a weirdly specific brag. Olivia adores it. Every time they drive past, she points it out, snaps a picture, and sends it to friends like she just spotted a celebrity.

Mikaela noticed. (Mikaela always notices.)

The almost-proposal

By this point, Olivia had been waiting on a proposal for a while. Long enough to set a deadline: before summer ends, and definitely before the new semester starts.

What she didn't know? Mikaela already had a plan. She'd propose on the tenth anniversary of the trip that first brought them together in Florence, which just happened to land right before Olivia's deadline.

One week before the big day, they drove to Rhode Island to visit Mikaela's sister. The ring was in Mikaela's keeping. Then they passed The Sign.

For one wild second, Mikaela almost tossed the whole plan and proposed right there at the highest elevation on I-90 east of the Rockies.

There was nowhere to pull over.

She stuck to the plan and proposed on the anniversary, at home, with their cats Thimble and Buttons (named for their shared love of sewing, obviously) supervising. Olivia only found out about the almost-moment later, and she's still delighted by it. Because that's the whole thing: Mikaela saw the tiny, silly thing Olivia loves and thought, that's where she'd love it most.

That's being known.

Spring wedding florals by Saint Rose Flowers at The Hillcrest Estate Photo by Bree Renee Photography

The ceremony

On April 11, 2026, Mikaela and Olivia got married at The Hillcrest Estate in Pavilion, NY.

They went unplugged, so every guest was fully present (and Bree Renee Photo got clean, phone-free shots). Each of them walked down the aisle with their dad, and we kicked things off with their love story, sign and all. Then every guest promised their love and support with a big community vow. The answer? A loud, happy "We will!"

Before the wedding, I asked each of them what they love most about the other.

Mikaela said it's the everyday magic: cooking together, sharing a look across the room, the cozy chaos of a home with Freya Jane, Charlie, Thimble, and Buttons. She loves how Olivia shows up for the people they love, especially Mikaela's parents and grandparents. She also loves that Olivia becomes, and I'm quoting the vibe here, nearly feral during trivia. She wouldn't change a thing.

Olivia said she loves Mikaela's curious, brilliant mind and the way she always asks what Olivia thinks. She loves that Mikaela heads outside the second the sun shows up and somehow still gets sunburned in fifty-degree weather. She loves her terrible sense of direction. She also loves that, every single month, Mikaela reminds her that If You Give a Mouse a Cookie is secretly an anti-communism metaphor, and the whole mess could've been avoided with a glass of milk. Because who eats a cookie without milk?

Instead of traditional vows, they each promised to keep the other as their favorite person: to laugh together, go on adventures, support each other through the hard stuff, grow old together, and share their french fries.

The french fries part is legally binding. I checked.

Mikaela and Olivia after their spring wedding in Upstate New York Photo by Bree Renee Photography

Why this one stuck with me

Some love stories are built on grand gestures. Mikaela and Olivia's is built on noticing. The sign. The trivia rage. The cookie theory. The little things that make someone them.

Congrats, Mikaela and Olivia. May your road trips always pass The Sign.

Mikaela and Olivia during their unplugged ceremony at The Hillcrest Estate in Pavilion, NY Photo by Bree Renee Photography

Want a ceremony that sounds like you?

Every Flower City Ceremonies wedding starts with your story: the sweet parts, the funny parts, and yes, the children's-book conspiracy theory parts. We craft ceremonies for every couple and every kind of love. If you want a ceremony your guests will still be quoting at cocktail hour, check out our Love Story package, which includes our Date Night Experience and help writing your vows.

Check your date with Flower City Ceremonies

The Dream Team ✨

Keri Klein

We’re an award-winning, all-inclusive team with one simple belief: life’s biggest moments deserve to be celebrated exactly as you are. We proudly honor love, identity, family, and legacy—without boxes, limits, or expectations.

We create meaningful ceremonies for:

Weddings

Vow Renewals

Elopements

Baby Naming & Welcoming

Trans-Naming Ceremonies

Funerals

Celebrations of Life

And anything in between that deserves to be named, honored, or remembered.

https://flowercityceremonies.com
Previous
Previous

Real Wedding: Alanna + Jon at Arbor Midtown

Next
Next

How to Get a Marriage License in New York