Some couples save for years for their wedding. Kat and Paul won theirs.
They were the winners of the Happily Ever After Wedding Giveaway: a fully planned ceremony and reception for up to 50 guests at Hilton Garden Inn Rochester/Pittsford, brought to life by a team of Rochester wedding pros. I was honored to be their officiant.
But their love story? That started with a golf tournament and a cover story that fell apart spectacularly.
Kat and Paul sharing a sweet moment at their wedding in Pittsford, NY photo by Jill Studio
How they met (eventually)
Kat and Paul actually worked at the same hospital over a decade ago and never met. Years later, their paths finally crossed through mutual friends.
Then Paul's buddy bailed on their trip to the PGA Championship in Kentucky (something about a broken foot). Paul knew Kat was a big golf fan, so he figured, why not ask her?
Kat said yes immediately.
photo by Jill Studio
The alibi
To get the time off, Kat told work she was going camping at Hershey Park with her sister.
Small problem: Hershey Park was closed. Bigger problem: Kat would never be caught sleeping in a tent.
Then Paul posted a very innocent drink flight on social media. Their boss noticed two glasses and the same out-of-office email, and the jig was up.
Their verdict? Totally worth it. They've been inseparable ever since.
The giveaway
In summer 2025, Rochester Wedding teamed up with Hilton Garden Inn Rochester/Pittsford and a lineup of local wedding pros for the Happily Ever After Wedding Giveaway. The prize was a fully planned wedding for up to 50 guests, with photography by Jill Studio, DJ J Nicole with Encore Events, rentals from McCarthy's Tents & Events, and yours truly as officiant.
Couples entered by sharing a photo and their love story. The vendor team (yes, including me) picked the finalists, and then the public voted. On July 15, 2025, Kat and Paul were announced as the winners. Ten weeks later, on September 28, they said "I will."
Honestly, after the Hershey Park incident, the universe owed them one.
The ceremony
On September 28, 2025, Kat and Paul got married at Hilton Garden Inn Pittsford.
Instead of a fully unplugged ceremony, we started with a "Social Media Moment." I stepped out of the way and gave every guest 30 seconds to snap all the photos they wanted. Then phones went away so everyone could be fully present for the rest. Guests get their shots, the photographer gets clear aisles, and everybody wins. (Fitting, for a love story that got busted on Instagram.)
Kat's stepdad walked her down the aisle, and her mom, Sheila, shared four readings: two chosen by Kat and two chosen by Paul. Then every guest promised their love and support with a community vow, and the answer came back loud: "We will!"
Before the wedding, I asked each of them what they love most about the other.
Paul admits he's "a bit of a nightmare to travel with." Kentucky was just a sampler. What he loves most about Kat is her patience. He's structured to a fault, and she never tries to change him. She just fills in the gaps, keeps him grounded, and still makes him laugh. She's got a killer sense of humor, she's an amazing cook, and she made his house feel like a home again.
Kat loves Paul's sense of humor: quick, clever, and just the right amount of ridiculous. He brought laughter and play back into her world. Her family even told her, "We have our old Kat back."
They each promised to keep the other as their favorite person: to laugh together, go on adventures, support each other, grow old together, and share their food. (Steak for Kat, ice cream for Paul. Priorities.) Then they shared the vows they wrote for each other.
Kat and her bridesmaids photo by Jill Studio
Why this one stuck with me
Kat and Paul remind me that the best stories aren't always the most polished ones. Sometimes it's a last-minute road trip, a cover story with more holes than a golf course, and two people who figured out they were worth getting caught for.
Congrats, Kat and Paul. You won the wedding, but honestly, you'd already won the bigger prize. May your road trips be fewer and your alibis better.
Kat and Paul sharing their Buffa-love of the Buffalo Bills and their dogs.
Want a ceremony that sounds like you?
Every Flower City Ceremonies wedding starts with your story: the sweet parts, the funny parts, and yes, the busted-by-your-boss parts. Want guests to snap their pics and then be fully present? Ask about our Social Media Moment. Check out our Love Story package, which includes our Date Night Experience and help writing your vows.
Check your date with Flower City Ceremonies
Vendor love
Venue: Hilton Garden Inn Rochester/Pittsford
Photography: Jill Studio
DJ: DJ J Nicole with Encore Events
Rentals: McCarthy's Tents & Events
Media partner: Rochester Wedding
Content creator: Gina Affronti, Simple Moment Shots
Officiant: Keri Klein, Flower City Ceremonies

