I opened Anna and Caleb's ceremony by welcoming "friends, family, and anyone here just for the cake."
That tells you everything about the vibe.
Anna and Caleb sharing their first kiss at their summer wedding at Shadow Lake in Penfield, NY photo by Rachel Ann Photography
How they met
Anna and Caleb matched on Tinder in the middle of the pandemic. Caleb isn't big on small talk, so he skipped it and invited Anna over to hang out. Anna said yes.
Then she showed up late. How late depends on who you ask. Anna says 30 minutes, fashionably. Caleb says 90 minutes, and possibly a test of his patience.
He waited anyway.
(Also, for the record, Caleb was not a serial killer. Always a relief.)
They talked every day after that first night and made it official that January. Since then, they've gotten through graduations, buying a house, and becoming parents to three very good dogs.
The proposal
Anna had one rule: no proposal at her master's graduation. So Caleb waited until Christmas.
With her parents, her niece, and her three nephews all in the room, Caleb sat there staring at a football game. Anna figured he was just really into it. He was actually just really, really nervous.
Then her dad muted the TV, and Caleb got down on one knee.
Best commercial break ever.
The pack
No Anna and Caleb story is complete without the dogs:
Okami, Caleb's loyal Alaskan Malamute
Zippy, a wiggly pit-boxer mix they adopted together
Elsa, a gentle Cane Corso who rounds out the crew
That's a lot of dog. They wouldn't have it any other way.
The ceremony
On July 5, 2025, Anna and Caleb got married at Shadow Lake in Penfield, NY, in a soft palette of navy, periwinkle, blush pink, and sage green.
The ceremony was unplugged so every guest was fully present. Anna's dad walked her down the aisle, and their priest opened with a blessing before we told their love story.
Anna and Caleb exchanged personal vows privately earlier that day, so in the ceremony I shared what each of them loves about the other.
Caleb said he knew from the start there was something extraordinary about Anna. Her patience calms him, and the way she loves him, fully and without hesitation, has changed his life. She sees him for exactly who he is. With her, he found his home.
Anna said Caleb is funny in all the best ways, smart, thoughtful, and protective in a way that makes her feel safe and supported. When the school year gets tough, he quietly makes life easier for her.
Here's my favorite detail: Anna's a music teacher, and Caleb comes to every single one of her concerts. Beginner orchestra, band, chorus. Every note, every squeak, every finale. He helps carry chairs and music stands, too, and he does it happily. When it's over, he tells her, "That was great," and she knows he means it.
Anna promised that no matter how long the concert runs, she'll always save him a seat.
They each promised to keep the other as their favorite person, then exchanged rings. To close, they did a love lock ceremony: two locks, one for each of them, locked together for good, with the keys set aside never to be used again.
Why this one stuck with me
Anna and Caleb's love shows up in the everyday stuff: waiting 90 (okay, maybe 30) minutes, carrying music stands, sitting through every beginner band concert, raising a house full of big dogs. That's the real stuff.
Congrats, Anna and Caleb. May your concerts always have a saved seat, and may Okami, Zippy, and Elsa never figure out where the treats are hidden.
Anna and Caleb newly married at Shadow Lake photo by Rachel Ann Photography
Want a ceremony that sounds like you?
Every Flower City Ceremonies wedding starts with your story: the sweet parts, the funny parts, and yes, the 90-minutes-late parts. Looking for a unity ritual beyond the candle? A love lock ceremony is a beautiful option, and our Love Story package includes help planning your unity ceremony, plus our Date Night Experience and help writing your vows.
Check your date with Flower City Ceremonies
Vendor love
Venue and catering: Shadow Lake
Photography: Rachel Ann Shipman Photography
Videography: Barnum Film
DJ: ROC the Party
Florist: Flower Barn
Cake: Savoia
Dress: Stella's Bridal
Suits: Jack Greens
Hair: Beauty by April Sunshine
Makeup: Devin Benulis Makeup
Rentals: Something Borrowed Rentals
Officiant: Keri Klein, Flower City Ceremonies

